#ad: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Is a Fiat 500 reliable long term? Here’s my honest update on my 2012 Pop, bought new, after 6 years and about 67,000 miles.
I cover what broke, what it cost, the upgrades I made to beat owner fatigue, and what the car is worth. My Aries floor liners have held up great, but I couldn’t find them listed now, so the box below links WeatherTech FloorLiners for the 500.
- Pretty worry-free and trouble-free over 6 years
- Good gas mileage and easy to park
- A champ in snow
- Repairs were cheap when things did break
- Coolant overflow reservoir cracked in extreme cold
- Tail light seal let in moisture after a car wash
- Radio button lettering starting to peel
- Resale value lower than I hoped
▶ Watch the full review on YouTube
Why I’m keeping it
About six months ago I switched to a job much closer to home, so my commute is under 15 miles a day. That sold me on re-upping with the Fiat. It’s a great commuter: good mileage, easy to park, easy in traffic.
I also had owner fatigue. My money hack: a few changes can give the car a newer feel and keep you from buying a much more expensive one.

Upgrades: wheels, decals and seats
The big one was a set of used Fiat 500 Sport wheels with new tires. Going from 15 to 16 inches made it look so much better.
My eBay decal set is peeling a little after 6 years of sun and winters, but it still looks pretty good. I’ve also priced leather seat covers from leatherseats.com (about $800 for the set) versus a used seat swap (about $1,000 with shipping). I haven’t pulled the trigger yet.

Floor liners and small wear items
My Aries floor liners, about $70, have been through a couple of winters and still fit well. I wish they had a softer, carpet-like feel, but they’ve saved my floor mats.
The number 2 radio button lettering is starting to peel, and the rear tail light got some condensation after a high-pressure car wash, so a seal is probably worn.

Repairs and what they cost
At 61,000 miles I had new pads and rotors installed. I bought the parts and a shop put them on cheaply. Brake dust hasn’t been bad.
Once, the LCD in the cluster went haywire on a winter drive home, then went back to normal after a restart and never happened again.
The polar vortex coolant leak
After a week parked outside at O’Hare in subzero weather, the car started fine but shifted hard, and I saw pink drops in the snow. I feared the transmission.
It was the coolant overflow reservoir, cracked along its seam, plus a leaking breather gasket. The dealer replaced both and flushed the coolant for $350.

Hitting a muffler at highway speed
At 70+ mph in heavy traffic, the SUV ahead straddled a muffler in my lane. I couldn’t swerve or slam on the brakes, so I took it down the center line and dragged it before it popped out the back.
It broke the lower crossmember. A shop removed it (two bolts), I bought the roughly $40 Fiat part, and he installed it for $15.
Resale value and verdict
I’d hoped it would hold $5,000-6,000 so I could swap into a used 500e, but I think it’s more of a $3,000-4,000 car, so the math doesn’t work.
Six years in, it’s been pretty worry-free. I’ll probably drive it a couple more years.
FAQ
Is the Fiat 500 reliable long term?
Mine has been pretty worry-free over 6 years and about 67,000 miles.
What was the most expensive repair?
$350 for a cracked coolant reservoir, a breather gasket and a coolant flush.
How is the Fiat 500 in snow?
It’s been a champ in snow for me.
What floor liners do you use?
Aries liners, about $70, still fitting well after a couple of winters.
Leave a Reply