Fiat 500 After 6 Years: Long-Term Ownership Review

#ad: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

2012 Fiat 500 Pop in gray with Sport wheels

Is a Fiat 500 reliable long term? Here’s my honest update on my 2012 Pop, bought new, after 6 years and about 67,000 miles.

I cover what broke, what it cost, the upgrades I made to beat owner fatigue, and what the car is worth. My Aries floor liners have held up great, but I couldn’t find them listed now, so the box below links WeatherTech FloorLiners for the 500.

WeatherTech FloorLiners for Fiat 500 (1st row)
Featured in this video
WeatherTech FloorLiners for Fiat 500 (1st row)
Check Fiat 500 floor liners on Amazon →
#ad, affiliate link
Quick specs (from the video)
Car2012 Fiat 500 Pop, bought new (about $17,000 out the door)
MileageAbout 67,000 at 6 years
BrakesNew pads and rotors at 61,000 miles (ceramic pads)
Coolant reservoir and breather gasket$350 at the dealer, including coolant flush
Lower crossmemberAbout $40 part + $15 labor after hitting a muffler
Floor linersAries, about $70, still fit after a couple of winters
My value estimateAbout $3,000-$4,000
👍 Pros
  • Pretty worry-free and trouble-free over 6 years
  • Good gas mileage and easy to park
  • A champ in snow
  • Repairs were cheap when things did break
👎 Cons
  • Coolant overflow reservoir cracked in extreme cold
  • Tail light seal let in moisture after a car wash
  • Radio button lettering starting to peel
  • Resale value lower than I hoped

▶ Watch the full review on YouTube

Why I’m keeping it

About six months ago I switched to a job much closer to home, so my commute is under 15 miles a day. That sold me on re-upping with the Fiat. It’s a great commuter: good mileage, easy to park, easy in traffic.

I also had owner fatigue. My money hack: a few changes can give the car a newer feel and keep you from buying a much more expensive one.

2012 Fiat 500 Pop with used Sport wheels
Used Sport wheels changed the look.

Upgrades: wheels, decals and seats

The big one was a set of used Fiat 500 Sport wheels with new tires. Going from 15 to 16 inches made it look so much better.

My eBay decal set is peeling a little after 6 years of sun and winters, but it still looks pretty good. I’ve also priced leather seat covers from leatherseats.com (about $800 for the set) versus a used seat swap (about $1,000 with shipping). I haven’t pulled the trigger yet.

Fiat 500 Pop cloth seats
The cloth seats I’d like to replace.

Floor liners and small wear items

My Aries floor liners, about $70, have been through a couple of winters and still fit well. I wish they had a softer, carpet-like feel, but they’ve saved my floor mats.

The number 2 radio button lettering is starting to peel, and the rear tail light got some condensation after a high-pressure car wash, so a seal is probably worn.

Fiat 500 instrument cluster at 67,000 miles
About 67,000 miles.

Repairs and what they cost

At 61,000 miles I had new pads and rotors installed. I bought the parts and a shop put them on cheaply. Brake dust hasn’t been bad.

Once, the LCD in the cluster went haywire on a winter drive home, then went back to normal after a restart and never happened again.

The polar vortex coolant leak

After a week parked outside at O’Hare in subzero weather, the car started fine but shifted hard, and I saw pink drops in the snow. I feared the transmission.

It was the coolant overflow reservoir, cracked along its seam, plus a leaking breather gasket. The dealer replaced both and flushed the coolant for $350.

Fiat 500 front end with the hood open
Under the hood: the coolant reservoir was replaced.

Hitting a muffler at highway speed

At 70+ mph in heavy traffic, the SUV ahead straddled a muffler in my lane. I couldn’t swerve or slam on the brakes, so I took it down the center line and dragged it before it popped out the back.

It broke the lower crossmember. A shop removed it (two bolts), I bought the roughly $40 Fiat part, and he installed it for $15.

Resale value and verdict

I’d hoped it would hold $5,000-6,000 so I could swap into a used 500e, but I think it’s more of a $3,000-4,000 car, so the math doesn’t work.

Six years in, it’s been pretty worry-free. I’ll probably drive it a couple more years.

FAQ

Is the Fiat 500 reliable long term?

Mine has been pretty worry-free over 6 years and about 67,000 miles.

What was the most expensive repair?

$350 for a cracked coolant reservoir, a breather gasket and a coolant flush.

How is the Fiat 500 in snow?

It’s been a champ in snow for me.

What floor liners do you use?

Aries liners, about $70, still fitting well after a couple of winters.

WeatherTech FloorLiners for Fiat 500 (1st row)
Ready to grab one?
WeatherTech FloorLiners for Fiat 500 (1st row)
Check Fiat 500 floor liners on Amazon →
#ad: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

4 responses to “Fiat 500 After 6 Years: Long-Term Ownership Review”

  1. How to Change a Fiat 500 Key Fob Cover (Easy DIY) – Peter von Panda Avatar
    How to Change a Fiat 500 Key Fob Cover (Easy DIY) – Peter von Panda

    […] What I’ve Learned About My Fiat 500 After Six Years […]

  2. How to Reset the Oil Change Light on a Fiat 500 – Peter von Panda Avatar
    How to Reset the Oil Change Light on a Fiat 500 – Peter von Panda

    […] What I’ve Learned About My Fiat 500 After Six Years […]

  3. How to Replace the Rear Wiper Blade on a Fiat 500 – Peter von Panda Avatar
    How to Replace the Rear Wiper Blade on a Fiat 500 – Peter von Panda

    […] What I’ve Learned About My Fiat 500 After Six Years […]

  4. 2015 Chevy Spark: What I Love and Hate (Rental Review) – Peter von Panda Avatar
    2015 Chevy Spark: What I Love and Hate (Rental Review) – Peter von Panda

    […] What I’ve Learned About My Fiat 500 After Six Years […]

Leave a Reply