#ad: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

I turned this into this.
I took a perfectly good bottle of Basil Hayden’s, mostly because I had another one. It’s a very good, affordable whiskey, and it’s what I usually use for Old Fashioneds, since I don’t like using a rich, expensive, smoky whiskey for that. But I love my Old Fashioneds rich and bold. So what if I oaked the living bejeebies out of the Basil Hayden’s? I put the whole bottle in a jar with oak spirals for six weeks to find out. There was a good chance it would be totally undrinkable.
- Easy: just a jar and some spirals
- Incredibly smooth, no bitterness
- Rich dried-fruit nose
- Great for Old Fashioneds
- Turns an affordable whiskey into something special
- Takes weeks
- Need to filter out wood bits
- Not smoky like I expected
- Easy to overdo with too many spirals
▶ Watch the full review on YouTube
The setup
I used a 1-liter jar, so the 750 ml bottle left a little room. Then I added four toasted oak spirals. They were too long, so I broke them in half and jammed them in, which means eight pieces. They’re medium-toast white oak; a heavy toast would make it even darker.
After six weeks in my liquor cabinet, it’s as dark as red wine, if not darker. In a super bright room, I can’t see through it.

What happened to the spirals
When I first put them in, they floated, as wood will. After a couple of days they got completely waterlogged and sank to the bottom. That’s a good sign the whiskey is working its way through the wood and pulling all that goodness out.

Filtering
I strained it through a coffee filter. It caught a lot of particulate and even a couple of big pieces of wood. What’s left is clear, oaked whiskey with a little red tinge and some caramel color.

How it tastes
The smell is very strong, but not in a bad way: alcohol, plus a really strong raisin and date, dried-fruit smell. It should still be about 80 proof, since a mason jar doesn’t lose anything to evaporation like a barrel.
It still has the heat of the alcohol on the back end, but it’s so smooth. No bitterness, a little creamy and subdued up front, buttery, almost oily. It’s not overly smoky like I expected. Raisin, date, maybe a hint of orange and a little apple. If I described it to a friend: a delicious, sugary, caramelly raisin of a whiskey.
My take
Six weeks with that many spirals worried me, but it’s freaking smooth. If you want to take a mediocre whiskey and make it fantastic, or make a good one even better, all you need is a mason jar and a couple of oak spirals. This is going to make one hell of an Old Fashioned.
FAQ
How long should oak spirals sit in whiskey?
I left four spirals (eight halves) in a 750 ml bottle for six weeks, and it came out very dark and very smooth.
Do oak spirals make whiskey smoky?
Mine didn’t taste smoky. It tasted like raisin, date and caramel.
Do you need to filter it?
Yes. I used a coffee filter to catch wood particles.
Is this an affiliate link?
Yes. The buttons are #ad affiliate links, and as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing extra.
Leave a Reply